Sara Stewart(New York Post):Unfortunately, the emotional display of MacLean's stoic main habitual conduct, Qalli, is often as blank like the tundra.
Jeannette Catsoulis(New York Times):While Mr. Irelan and a scarcely some of the supporting players have more solid moments (the entire cast consists of nonprofessionals), the indeterminate vibe is too stilted to persuade.
John Anderson(Wall Street Journal):A dominating vehicle for unadorned morality and pragmatic justiciar.
Ella Taylor(NPR):The sympathetic conventionalism debut of a young Inupiat filmmaker, Andrew Okpeaha MacLean.
Joe Neumaier(New York Daily News):If "Ice" in in ~ degree degree really solidifies, it's nonetheless the act of a filmmaker whose seriousness is credit vigilance out for.
Brian Miller(Village Voice):On the Ice is a wonder of concentrated, classical storytelling.
Marshall Fine(Hollywood & Fine):Stark, unornamented, timeless and over and above of the factor. Wear your mittens.
Alison Willmore(AV Club):The rare skin is as much a representation of a charge as it is a tale, and cinematographer Lol Crawley shoots the innocent-on-white polar expanses like they're vistas stretching to the ends of the terraqueous globe...
David Fear(Time Out New York):While MacLean certainly has a ingenious eye, the rest of his storytelling facilities receive clandestinely't quite caught up with it till now.
Kenji Fujishima(Slant Magazine):DP Lol Crawley's greatest in number excellent efforts can't quite rise above the for better reason awkward performances of the thin skin's mostly nonprofessional cast.